Alright. I haven’t written anything in a while, and I think that sucks. Jen’s been picking up the slack, which is great, but I think I need to show some real commitment to Brunchtastic. I can’t get lazy now that I’ve achieved my goal of fame and fortune on the interweb.
To show my dedication, I went ahead and shelled out the big bucks (nothing really, for a baller like me), and went to craftbar, Chef Tom Colicchio’s elaborate wine bar restaurant in the not-so-lower east side. Actually it was a friends birthday, but still, I had my review in mind the entire time.
Here’s what I ordered:
To start, I ordered Le Serena. A very thick and creamy Spanish sheep cheese. It was served with two slices of cranberry walnut bread. It was really good, and stinky. I happen to like spreadable stinky cheeses like this one.
For my main course I got the Scottish Salmon with Apples, Smoked Bacon, and Brussels Sprouts. This dish left a lot to be desired. While the fish was cooked well, with a nice crust on the top, the supporting ingredients fell far short of my expectations. The fish was served on a bed of the Brussels sprouts with diced apples and the smoked bacon. The flavors were nice together, but they went so light on the bacon and apples that you could barely taste them. Subtle flavor is nice, especially when you’re dealing with fish, but there has to be a limit. Also, the dish as a whole lacked acidity. There was no citrus, not nothing. This, as I said before, was disappointing.
I didn’t end up getting desert, as by the end of the meal I had built up a substantial bill. A few of the other diners did however, and I have to say everything looked great, so I’m assuming it was.
Lastly, and this is really what put me over the edge as far as disliking the meal is concerned, the service was really not what it should have been. The wait staff seemed kind of clueless, which at times was incredibly frustrating. For example, I ordered a beer at the beginning of the meal, and I was looking for a little assistance from the server as to what I could have expected from a particular IPA. When I asked her to describe the beer, her responce was, “It’s good. People like it. So you want one?” Thats wrong in so many ways.
First, that’s not what I asked her. Second, I don’t care if people like it. A lot of people like a lot of different things, and most of them suck, so whatever. And lastly, don’t peddle your food on me. I’m paying a lot as it is, so don’t try to up-sell me, it’s in poor taste. Not to mention, the beer was pretty balls. It was Impaled Ale, a pretty dark local IPA, if any of you care.
So, my final thoughts on craftbar are that you probably shouldn’t go. While in most cases I’d revel at the opportunity to bash celebrity chef’s restaurant, and by extension of that, the celebrity chef himself, that just doesn’t feel right in this situation. In experiencing craftbar just once, it’s become abundantly clear that it’s not so much a restaurant as it is a wine bar with overpriced food. There is a huge wine selection, and a really subdued comfortable feel to the place. The party I was with had a late reservation, so we were sitting around until around midnight, and there were still a bunch of patrons sitting around, drinking wine. That, in conjunction with the lack of attention payed to the actual dining experience, leads me to believe the place serves the ulterior motive of boozing up the rich and lame. So, if you happen to be into that kind of thing then maybe you should check it out for yourself. Then again, that would make you a fatty d-bag.